Well, I did it - I went a whole month without making a single post on my blog…
Ho hum.
I’m sitting in my room, it’s Friday night, half past eleven, and I’m listening to ‘Live Over Europe’, the CD of Genesis Reunion Tour they did this year.
Genesis have been my favourite band for the last fifteen years at least (Spock’s Beard are currently giving them a serious run for their money at the mo, but I will give it a few years before I make an actual decision on that score). Last year or the year before, a rumour started on the internet that they were going to reunite for a gig. I would pay any amount of money to see that, so I was naturally very excited.
Then it turned out that the reunion rumours were true, but that it was to consist of Phil, Tony and Mike - the latter years lineup. No Peter Gabriel, no Steve Hackett.
Shit, thought I - there’s no point in going then. The five of them together acheived pinnacles of musical creativity almost unrivalled, but after Peter and Steve left, they lapsed into mediocrity. Don’t get me wrong, they still made good songs, but nothing really to touch the dizzying heights of ‘Firth of Fifth’ or ‘Suppers Ready’ for example (except for the beginning and end of Duke and the end of Fading Lights maybe). I elected not to pursue tickets.
After it was too late to get tickets (they sold out quite quickly), I thought that maybe I had erred in my decision. Yeah, it was not the original lineup, but it was still most of Genesis, and they were bound to play a fair few of their older songs. Besides, it was probably the only time I would get to see them anyway, as the possibility of the classic lineup reuniting was looking all but nonexistant (and still does).
Too late. I didn’t lose any sleep over it or anything.
So here I am, listening to an album of one of the concerts (Manchester, I believe), and to be honest………..I’m glad I didn’t bother.
Nine songs from the classic years, and three of those are lumped together into a medley (In The Cage, The Cinema Show, Duke’s Travels). They allow Firth of Fifth merely an excerpt… I Know What I Like - why do they keep dredging that one up? The Carpet Crawlers, done solely because they re-recordd it in ‘99. Ripples - they seem to have picked the least prog they could find.
Afterglow (one of my favourites), usually a lingering majestic closer to a set, has been lumped in the middle and given only a cursory run through.
I know that if I had gone to see it, I would have gotten all excited leading up to the gig, and come out with a broken heart. Listening to this album, it reminds me of how much they have abandoned their prog roots, as if they were ashamed of it, paying it lip service only because some of the fans want to hear it. Daryl Steurmer (I assume) slaughtering the guitar solo of Firth of Fifth with a load of unnecessary extra notes (I fucking hate it when he does that). Phil Collins churning out the same old bollocks with the crowd that he always does (I’m two thirds through the album and he hasn’t said a word to the crowd - he’s just done the ‘be da daaaaaaay’ stuff to Throwing It All Away that he’s done so many times before (This could have been just another gig from their ‘The Way We Walk’ Tour - what’s the point?). Tony Banks selects some really awful synth voices these days - this gig has no atmosphere (granted I’m listening to a CD recording, but still…). Oh, I am so glad I didn’t go. Talk about going through the motions.
To be able to see the five of them reunite for just one gig…To see Suppers Ready, Watcher of the Skies, Seven Stones, The Lamia, Dancing With The Moonlit Knight, Firth Of Fifth (I got a tear in my eye seeing Steve play that at a solo gig - imagine how I’d be seeing all five of them perform it again), The Musical Box, The Cinema Show, Dance on a Volcano, In That Quiet Earth, and what a mesmerising finale it would be to hear Peter give his voice to Afterglow as a finale (for the uninitiated, Afterglow was recorded after Peter left)…..now that would be a concert…